Wondering if you smoke your turkey or deep fry it?
A big reason why I love cooking is creativity, but for you, it might be convenience. So below I’ll compare the pros and cons of smoking a turkey compared to frying it.
So hopefully it helps you to decide which method to go with!
Comparing Smoking & Frying A Turkey
Below I have set out the key differences between each of these methods.
Which are in chronological order of cooking. From the preparation to some safety advice.
Each of these methods has excellent flavor.
The aim is to base opinions on personal circumstances.
Do you want a quicker cooking time? Do you understand the dangers of frying oil?
Equipment- Smoked Vs Fried Turkey
This covers the equipment needed when preparing to cook the turkey.
Both methods will need the standard BBQ utensils when cooking.
Both methods will require at least 2 instant-read thermometers.
For a smoked turkey you will need a type of smoker that is situated outside. The fuel you will use for smoking will depend on the smoker.
An electric pellet grill smoker gives you complete control of the temperature.
Using compact wood chips or pellets. They come in different flavors like apple wood or cherry wood.
A traditional charcoal smoker works too.
Charcoal briquettes are recommended for a long cooking time.
You may have to consider meat hooks or a wire rack to hang the turkey. But putting it directly on the cooking grate works fine.
For frying a turkey we recommend a special turkey fryer. This is a deep fryer made big enough to fit a larger turkey of 30 pounds!
Deep frying requires oil and lots of it! I recommend vegetable oil as it has a high smoke point.
You want to be able to submerge the bird.
A frying rod is also required to hang through the cavity. So you can safely submerge and head to the meat church!
The heat source is a propane burner. Oh, and don’t forget plenty of paper towels to remove excess oil when finished!
Seasoning – Smoked Vs Fried Turkey
Seasoning turkey is crucial for your recipe. This meat can handle a strong spice rub or a fresh herb stuffing.
When smoking turkey the flavors and juices have time to incorporate.
A spice rub with Cajun seasoning and brown sugar will caramelize to golden skin.
Fresh ingredients stuffed into the bird won’t burn. The possibilities are endless when seasoning a smoked turkey.
Seasoning a turkey for deep frying is different than smoking.
Do not use any fresh herbs or aromatics like cloves of garlic or fresh thyme. These will burn and can even be a safety hazard.
A light coating of a spice rub on the outside is fine. If you want to infuse flavor then use a meat injector.
Make an oil-based marinade of your choice. Olive oil, lemon juice, and garlic powder come to mind.
Inject into the thickest parts like the thighs and breasts.
The Cooking Method – Smoked Vs Fried Turkey
The cooking method between smoking and frying is well…
Smoking and frying!
Indirect heat and smoke will slowly cook the turkey.
Total submersion in oil cooks the turkey with direct heat.
Cooking Temperatures – Smoked Vs Fried Turkey
The cooking temperature between smoking and frying is vastly different.
The best smoking temperature for turkey ice cream between 225°F – 275°F.
The oil temperature when frying turkey can reach between 350°F – 400°F.
Cooking Times – Smoked Vs Fried Turkey
Let’s say we have a 12-pound turkey ready to cook.
At 225°F a 12-pound turkey will take 360 minutes. (6 hours). Which is at an average of 30 minutes per pound.
At 400°F a 12-pound turkey can take just 1 hour! Which is at an average rate of 5-10 minutes per pound.
Taste – Smoked Vs Fried Turkey
The taste will depend on the seasonings used in the recipe.
A smoked turkey will have a rich flavor from the slow cooking time. The flavors have had more time to develop.
The additional flavor from the charcoal or wood pellets impacts the taste.
Turkey is primarily lean but does contain fat and connective tissue.
Smoking renders these down into juicy meat. The outer skin will be caramelized and golden.
A fried turkey will take on the flavor of the oil you use.
It may not have been seasoned as well to avoid any burning. But the high-intensity heat brings out that delicious fried flavor we know and love.
I also think the natural flavor of the meat is more prominent.
The gamey taste of the dark meat in the thighs. Or the delicate and sweet taste of the white meat in the breasts.
Not forgetting the decadent crisp skin that has popped and rendered!
Texture – Smoked Vs Fried Turkey
The texture is a key part when enjoying any recipe. The meat texture is very similar with the only contrast in the skin.
Smoked turkey done right is moist and tender. The long cooking time causes it to fall apart.
The skin transformed into a golden brown crust.
Break into the hard crispy turkey skin and reveal succulent meat.
The moisture evaporation from the proteins is stopped when the skin seals. So the meat has steamed in its juices.
Safety – Smoked Vs Fried Turkey
This is a very important part when cooking on any device.
A well-built smoker is easy to maintain and can even be left when cooking.
Just make sure you have enough fuel to last the cooking time and you have followed the proper cleaning and maintenance procedures.
You should always smoke outside and in a well-ventilated area. Have a fire extinguisher ready or a gallon of water if your smoker isn’t electrically powered.
Fry turkey with extreme caution. Not to dramatize but it can be very dangerous.
Even a little excess moisture can cause a fire or explosion.
Designate an area for the fryer that only you have access to. Make any guests aware of the dangers and be careful of children.
Have an extinguisher on hand. Remove any ignition devices from the propane tank.
Do not keep any water near the fryer and monitor the weather.
Dry out the turkey in the fridge the night before. Make sure it has fully thawed.
If you drop a frozen turkey into the oil it can explode.
The Internal Temperatures For Turkey Meat
There are 2 types of meat in a turkey.
These both need different internal temperatures before eating. Always use a meat thermometer to know check.
Food poisoning from poultry is no joke!
The digital probe in the dark thigh and leg meat should read 180°F.
The digital probe in the white breast meat should read 165°F.
Pros & Cons Of Smoking A Turkey
– Smoking is a safer method.
– More ways to incorporate flavor.
– Higher moisture retention in the meat.
– Can prepare in advance with less supervision.
– Need a specialist smoker to fit a turkey.
– Longer cooking time and planning.
– The skin has a higher risk of going soggy.
Pros & Cons Of Frying A Turkey
– Quick cooking time.
– A delicious and satisfying crispy skin.
– Limited seasoning and flavor infusion.
– Constant supervision due to the dangers.
– Requires specialist turkey fryer and equipment.
Author: Charlie Reeves
Hi, I’m Charlie, I am head taste tester at Simply Meat Smoking! I love it grilling, smoking, and getting out in the yard with the kids! The family also love to test all my recipes (especially my EXTRA CRISPY pulled pork, smoky pork loin, and ANY SEAFOOD I grill)
You will usually find me playing with the kids, perfecting my brisket bark, or sipping beers with the boys around the fire. Can’t wait to share all my delicious smoking and grilling adventures with you!
You can read more on our About Us page.
Hungry For More?