Salted 2 Way Brownies with Cookie Dough

Advertising

Happy holidays are on their way, and so are some new desserts! The first one is called Salted 2 Way Brownies. They’re fudge brownies with cookie dough baked in to make chocolate brownies filled with chewy chocolate chip cookies. They’re super easy, and I think once you buy your ingredients you’ll have a good time making them.

Brownies with cookie dough baked in.
Salted 2 Way Brownies are fudge brownies cookie dough baked in.

I like to call these kinds of recipes “beach house recipes”. They’re perfect for when you’re staying somewhere temporarily and need a recipe that doesn’t call for a lot of ingredients and equipment.

Brownies with cookie dough on top
Brownie batter with squares of cookie dough on top.

North Carolina State Fair Winner

And not only are these convenient, they are special because the brownies won first place at the North Carolina State Fair. The original recipe is by Emoni Jennings, who wrote exactly which brands of brownie mix and cookie dough to use for perfect results. Me being me, I improvised a bit. My changes were to use a different variety of Betty Crocker brownie mix, a different cookie dough and I drizzled the baked brownies with some melted Werther’s Originals, which took an extra 2 minutes.

Salted 2 Way Brownies are brownies with cookie dough baked in.
Salted 2 Way Brownies

Despite going off the recipe, the brownies were good. I like the flavor of homemade brownies spirit packaged brownie mix brownies, so using a mix was a benefit — especially in my transient kitchen situation. I plan on making these again with mixes, and experimenting with a scratch version. But if you don’t want to go wrong the first time, I recommend trying it with the brownie mix and packaged cookie dough.

Salted 2 Way Brownies Ingredients Notes and Tips

  • Fudge Brownie Mix — The original recipe calls for 1 box of Betty Crocker brand fudge brownie mix which you prepare and bake in an 8 inch square pan. I used Betty’s Triple Chunk, which worked well, but might have a different bake time, as mine took longer than the original recipe. In addition to the mix you will most likely need an egg, oil and water or whatever the mix calls for.
  • Nestle Cookie Dough – You can cut it off a roll or use the pre-formed squares as you see in the photo. Using the squares was a breeze! The only drawback to the cookie dough is that it browns faster than the brownies bake, so you may need to shield the brownies with a sheet of foil along the way.
  • Chocolate Morsels — You can use a full bag of milk chocolate chips or semisweet chips. One of theses days I’ll try with the milk (probably sooner than later), but I used good quality semisweet and they worked just fine. Because I used brownie mix with chips already in it, I didn’t need to use the full bag.
  • Caramel Drizzle — Added because I had a bag of Werther’s Soft Caramel in the house. All I had to do was mix about 5 pieces of caramel with a teaspoon of water and microwave until melted. This made the perfect caramel for drizzling.
  • Maldon Salt or Any Salt — Big flaky salt really adds some character to this recipe, but if you just have some kosher salt around, that should work too.

Brownies with Cookie Dough

Salted 2 Way Brownies from the NC State Fair

Anna

A state fair winning recipe for brownies with chocolate chip cookies baked right in!

Prep Time 10 my s

Cook Time 33 my s

Cooling 2 hrs

Course Dessert

Cuisine American

Instructions

  • Preheat oven to 350 degrees or if your brownies mix says otherwise, use that heat. Line a lightly greased 8 or 9 inch square pan with parchment paper. Note that if you use an 8 inch pan the brownies will need a few minutes longer in the oven and you may need to shield them to keep the cookies from getting to brown.

  • In a large mixing bowl, prepare brownie mix as directed on the box using egg(s), oil and water as called for. Stir in the chocolate morsels.

  • If using a roll of cookie dough, slice 1-inch thick pieces of cookie dough into roughly 8-10 slices. For smaller cookies, cut the 8 to 10 slices in half. If using the pre-formed cookie dough, you can skip this step.

  • Pour brownie batter into the baking dish and spread evenly. Arrange sliced ​​cookie dough pieces (or squares) evenly across top of brownie batter.

  • Place baking dish into oven and bake as directed on the box for the size of pan you used. Again, if using an 8 inch pan the cookies may brown faster than the brownies bake, so you may want to shield the pan with a sheet of foil. I used a box of Betty Crocker Triple Chocolate and it took 38 minutes. I did not shield the pan and the cookies were very brown (but still delicious!). The original recipe calls for an 8 inch pan and a 20-25 minute baked time, so if using Betty Crocker Fudge Brownies you may be able to pull at 25.

  • The best way to check if the brownies are done is with an instant read thermometer. Mine topped out at 180 degrees F. and were very soft in the center. I think you’ll be okay with an internal temperature anywhere between 180 and 210 F.

  • While the brownies are still hot, sprinkle sea salt evenly across the top of the brownies. Set the brownies aside for 10 minutes to cool. If using caramels, put the caramels in a small microwave-safe dish with a teaspoon of water. Heat on high for 20 seconds. Stir. Repeat if necessary until caramel is melted, then drizzle over brownies. Add a little more sea salt.

  • Let the brownies cool for several hours or overnight. Cut and serve.

Keyword Betty Crocker, Nestle Cookie Dough

More Brownies that are Unusual

Reader Interactions

Leave a Comment